Golden Staters Brace for a Shoot-Out with the Tax Bandits

Like a bad zombie movie where no one really dies, California’s “split roll property tax” is back. The last time it had a heartbeat was in 2015 via the so-called “Make it Fair” initiative, which was headed for the ballot in 2016. But due to some Democratic pushback, the proposition was pulled, much to the consternation of public employee unions and other leftist tax grabbers.

Now the same bunch that failed to usher in this misery-laden tax in 2015 is planning to revive it in 2020 with the claim that it would raise $11 billion a year for schools and local governments. In a nutshell, the “split roll” initiative would gut Prop 13 protections for businesses, but spare individuals the massive tax hike. Since 1978, Prop. 13 has limited property taxes on all forms of property – private and commercial – to 1 percent of assessed value, and limits increases in that value to no more than 2 percent a year, except when properties change hands.

But the proposed commercial tax bump would be a disaster for California. It would increase business costs, which would then be passed on to others, resulting in higher lease and rental prices, higher product prices, a reduction in employees and the salaries of those remaining, as well as a cutback in overall economic activity. A March 2012 study from Pepperdine University’s School of Public Policy showed that adopting such a “split-roll” property tax would result in a loss of 400,000 jobs and $72 billion in economic activity in the first five years.

For those of you who don’t live in California, it’s important to note that the state is hardly tax-starved. As San Diego tax warrior Richard Rider points out, we have the highest state income tax rate, sales tax and gas pump tax in the country, as well as the second highest corporate income tax rate of all states west of Iowa.

Now for some good news. The bill’s inept honchos can’t seem come up with the right wording. After getting the required number of signatures (almost 600,000) to appear on the 2020 ballot, the proponents yanked the first version of the bill in August because they felt its flaws would prevent it from winning at the polls. So they “fixed” the proposition and refiled it the same month. The bad news for them is that by then it required getting almost a million signatures to qualify it for the ballot. Then, a few weeks later they pulled the reworked prop – before gathering signatures this time – and revamped it again. So we are now on version 3… and counting. As reported by Citizen’s Journal, the latest amendments appear to be in response to a September 10th letter from the California Assessors’ Association that criticized many provisions of the initiative, declaring that the measure is “both ambiguous in some sections and overly narrow in other sections,” and “will create significant unintended consequences for ALL property owners, including homeowners and small business owners.”

Needless to say, regardless of all the problematic details, the teachers unions are drooling over the potential windfall.To continue reading, go to


  1. Stan Sexton says

    If this passes, you’ll see a ton of “Home-Based” businesses and a ton of vacancies in commercial properties aimed at small business as rents rise. All businesses in Calif will be less competitive. Look for out-of-states internet purchases to increase.The question is how are you going to tax the remaining lower class to fund the utopia when the middle class leaves?

  2. The “check engine” light is on as the parasitic unions and their paid for politicians stomp on the gas petal.

  3. ExCaliExpat says

    Find out who is writing this bill, vote them out of office and anyone who supports it….
    Elections have consequences….
    Time to rise up against these SOB’s….

    • Boris Badenov says

      I wish we could vote the idiots that sign to put this nonsense on the ballot off the island. We need to eliminate paid petition gatherers. This nonsense would stop.

  4. Why would ANYONE, even liberals vote for another tax increase of any kind. The Guv just announced he was diverting gas tax money voted on for road, to go to affordable housing and rail projects. People need to see the results of previous taxes before voting in new ones.

  5. Divide and conquer. First the business property then, the residential

Speak Your Mind