Prop. 66 Looks to Speed Up Executions on Death Row

Death PenaltyTomorrow, voters will consider not one but two measures involving the death penalty — one speeds up the process while the other would stop it entirely.

If approved, Prop. 62 would repeal the death penalty and commute the condemned sentences to life without parole. On the other hand, Prop. 66 would speed up the process by expanding the number of courts and attorneys able to hear and try death penalty appeals to meet a five-year cap on the appeals process that currently takes decades. (If both measures pass, the highest vote-getter would become law.)

But failure to meet the five-year time frame would not commute the sentence or throw out the appeal, according to the proposed language. So what happens at the five-year mark?

“If the process takes more than five years, victims or their attorneys could request a court order to address the delay,” said Drew Soderborg, managing principal analyst with the state’s Legislative Analyst’s Office. “Because it is unknown how often this would happen or how courts would rule on such a requests, it is difficult to know what the effect would be.”

A court order could pump a sense of urgency into whichever party or court is holding up the process — the violation of which could be punishable in some instances.

Is the system broken?

Proponents of both measures agree that the current system is broken. The appeals process takes decades at a tremendous cost to the state ($55 million annually), which has to prosecute as well as defend in many instances.

Because of legal complications with the lethal injection process, the state hasn’t executed anyone since 2006. In fact, only 15 inmates have been executed since 1978, while 100 have died while waiting, according to an LAO analysis of the measure.

Currently, there are around 750 inmates on Death Row. Some supporters of a total repeal of the death penalty argue it’s a cruel and unusual punishment, while others point to exonerations, which, while not entirely common, happen frequently enough to worry critics about executing innocent people. Since 1973, 156 people have been exonerated nationwide, including three in California, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

Prop. 66 would reform the system in an entirely different way — by speeding it up. The measure would increase the pool of eligible attorneys qualified to represent condemned inmates by forcing them to do it. Many who are qualified don’t like to represent death penalty appeals because of inadequate state funding and the major time commitment.

The number of courts in which cases could be heard would be increased under Prop. 66 by sending one type of appeal (habeas corpus petitions) back to the initial court to see if any error had been made. As of April, there were 360 Death Row inmates waiting for habeas corpus petitions.

Critics say Prop. 66’s five-year cap is arbitrary. But proponents say it’s enough time in most instances.

“Prop. 66 limits state appeals to 5 years instead of allowing  convicted criminals to file appeal after appeal after appeal,” said Bill Bradley, a spokesman for Prop. 66. “However, the initiative does not impose a rigid deadline that must be met in every case as extraordinary cases may take longer. With that said, five years is generally sufficient to get through state appeals, even in the most complex cases.”

This piece was originally published by CalWatchdog.com

Comments

  1. Wake up people — the person with the death sentence just got through a trial and were found guilty and given death… and now they want to appeal to another court to get the penalty removed….Let’s change the death penalty timing to 60 days and POOF — your dead… This is all manure for lawyers to argue about on tax dollars.. Death should be immediate if found guilty by the trial…. A superior court must review the trial within 60 days and if they do not find a valid reason to lay the sentence aside, the sentence is carried out on schedule.. Enough of this storage of killers….

  2. retiredxlr8r says

    I’m tired of weak and pathetic people, let alone the ignorant ones.
    I’m going to go with God on this one (see Gen 9:6).
    And, of course the “swift justice” in the original concept of American justice. None of this one appeal after the other until the Supreme Court rules. If the locals can’t do it they need to be replaced.
    Positive proof and accomplished within a brief time period, nothing over 90 days. Full court, tough, justices can work around the clock in shifts. In a short time the courts will be back to only two to three days a week.

  3. A major problem with “life without parole” is that it does not mean “life without parole.” The powers that be in Sacramento seem to look for any reason to put dangerous criminals back on the street.

  4. ……”while others point to exonerations, which, while not entirely common, happen frequently enough to worry critics about executing innocent people. ”
    D.A.s know that the chances of death of the condemned by execution, is highly unlikely (and made to be so, contrary to the will of the People).
    Restoration of the death penalties vigour would discourage D.A.s from using captial punishment charges as a gambit (as is done now) to coerse a copped plea to lesser charges. So much for a “significant percentage” of wrongful sentencing.

  5. I retired from law enforcement in 1984 and there are still three douche bags living on Death Row that were from this county before I left. One guy bragged about what he did. Stabbed his roommates wife multiple times and tried to booby trap the house so a then nine year old would have been hurt if she came to see why her mom was screaming.

    Mom died – after being brutally raped.
    The husband went off the rails because she was the love of his life.
    The kid later went on to commit suicide because she was so screwed up.

    The douche bag is on Death Row on our dime and is no where close to seeing the inside of the lethal injection chamber that he so richly deserved many many years ago.

    Wake UP Libtards – rapidly take out the ones that are obviously guilty as there is no redemption for scumbags like this.

  6. Hang them! Rope is cheap, and that is better than they deserve!

Speak Your Mind

*